Single Island Shores
★ 4.75Hector, NY
Most people hear New York and think of the city. But most of the state is woods, lakes and small towns, and a lot of it is a long way from a subway. The Adirondacks alone are bigger than some states.
Every place here is rated highly by guests and sits close to trails, water or a good fire. These are the ones we'd send a friend to, sorted by region.
Adirondack Park covers about six million acres in the north of the state, a mix of public forest, private land and small towns. It has thousands of lakes and ponds and the 46 High Peaks, including Mount Marcy, the highest point in New York.
Lake Placid, Keene Valley and Wilmington are the easiest base for the High Peaks. Farther south, around North Creek and Schroon Lake, it's lower and quieter.
The Catskills are closer to the city, maybe two to three hours depending on traffic, so they get busy on weekends. Still, there's a lot of state forest up there, and once you're off the main roads it gets quiet fast.
Woodstock and Phoenicia are the towns people know. Windham and Hunter are the ski towns. The western side, around Fleischmanns and Roxbury, is farther out and calmer.
A row of long, skinny lakes in the middle of the state, with vineyards on the slopes and waterfalls in the gorges. Seneca and Cayuga are the biggest. Keuka is the one shaped like a Y.
Watkins Glen, at the south end of Seneca, has a gorge trail that passes 19 waterfalls. Ithaca, at the bottom of Cayuga, has more gorges than it knows what to do with.
Hector, NY
Separate cottages on the east side of Seneca Lake, each with a balcony over the water. There's a shared deck on the lake and fire pits for sunset. Simple inside, but you're there for the view.
Up on the St. Lawrence River, along the Canadian border, there are more than 1,800 islands. Some have a single cabin on them. Alexandria Bay and Clayton are the main towns, and summer is the season.
Wilmington, NY
Wilmington, NY
New places we find and the odd guide to somewhere quiet. A few emails a year, that's it.