Reviews of Old Town Inn

Excellent breakfast, friendly staff.

I am definitely going back for a longer stay

The Inn is lovely. The owner was very friendly and a good source of information. The breakfast was delicious. Definitely one of the nicest most comfortable places I’ve ever stayed.

Better than expected!!!

Breakfasts were awesome! The BEST !!!

Not a thing!

Beautiful property and very friendly staff.

Nice and quiet but it is close to everything.

Would definitely recommend.

Breakfast - amazing! Facilities - also amazing!

Loved the location as slightly out of the hustle and bustle of town. However, the downside was the very expensive taxi ride for the very short distance to and from the town ($18 each way). Biking to and from the town was great once we had rented bikes.

Everything , amazing staff, great rooms can’t wait to go back

The property was spacious and had plenty of spots to hang out and enjoy a drink at!

Staff was great. Breakfast was great I just wish they had ice tea made but maybe there’s not enough people that drink it for breakfast.

The only thing I wish is they have a tv in the room in case you want down time to yourself and to watch it. They do have one in living room though.

A wonderful getaway in an idyllic setting!

Staff was absolutely lovely. they let us leave our backpacks as we arrived several hours early. Our room was ready before the 3 check in time. Room was spotless and breakfast was delicious and homemade as we sat on the deck drinking tea and coffee and juice. Location was perfect and easy to find. We had a wonderful two days on the island!!!

Not a single complaint.

Very happy with my stay.

The garden was beautiful and very welcoming. The whole inn and the room were very clean and charming to stay in. Breakfast was very good and fresh!

So comfortable, easy, and friendly

Quiet and walkable to town Pet friendly Beautiful upgraded environment

Great property for couples . I highly recommend this.

Breakfast was very good. We liked the outside deck as a place to sip coffee

Nothing off hand. If there was a complimentary shuttle from the ferry that would be a nice plus.

Cosy, staff lovely

Bed a bit small!

Great location and breakfast!

The property was beautifully maintained outside and the inside was spotless.

Breakfast was delicious. Staff wonderfull,

I highly recommend staying here! We will definitely stay here again! Thank you so much for everything

Everyone was very welcoming and it felt like home! Breakfast in the morning was delicious

Everything was amazing, thank you!!

Delightful, relaxing and all needs addressed before anything needed:))

Gracious. welcoming. clean and cares for

all good

🎉 Perfection 🎉

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ EXCEPTIONAL! Neal and his staff are so welcoming and kind. Our room was gorgeous and oh so comfortable. The grounds and the many seating areas all have amazing views of the property. There are numerous spots with Adirondack chairs and tables, rocking chairs, a gazebo lounge area, hammock, gardens, resident ducks and a comfy fire pit to relax at night under the stars. Full breakfast is available in the dining room or outside on the multi level deck. The sweetest girls brought our breakfast and checked frequently to be sure everything was perfect. We came to the island for our son's wedding. The entire experience was perfection from beginning to end! We'll be back again ❤️